Im so confused about people saying they prefer the ai one. Just to double triple check that were all on the same page here, the ai one is the bottom one, right??
I think the bottom one is extremely boring and the top one looks sick af.
I thought AI was the top one. I actually prefer the AI one in this case. in the first one the guy’s face and nose is square and the the drawing is shitty. the second is clear and not distracting
If the person holding Trump was a caricature of an Israeli many would have lost their minds and called it antisemitic. But when it is an Arab no one cares about antisemitism anymore.
The AI image looks a bit less racist. Original author made the Arab head completely flat to insinuate they have no brains.
Might be an unpopular opinion but honestly the ai one isnt even that bad
- It’s a knock-off copy of an original idea
- The copy missed an important detail, clearly intended by the original artist: Trump’s face. In the original artwork Trump is pictured as oblivious to the situation, making the plane noises, acting childish. In the statistical engine generated image, no such emotion is depicted.
- A few important details, actually. In the original the Qatari is looking straight at the “camera”, in a kind of “see this?” way.
- Sloppy gen artifacts everywhere
I think I prefer the AI one just because I don’t understand what they are going for with Trump’s face in the original. I assume he’s supposed to look like something specific that I’m not understanding.
Is it that hard to criticize Arab leaders for their politics without being racist about it?
Hm neither one looks particularly like Sheikh Tamim bin Hamad al-Thani, and the headdress style is Saudi Arabian in both.
I wonder how the Borderlands stuff would look of run through ai.
I’m seeing this shitty AI style with the thick lines everywhere. It triggers a deep rage in my lizard brain like Corporate Memphis does but it’s much worse
Is this meant to be a test of this sub or a joke? Second one actually knows how to draw a face. Wtf is going on in the top? Are these mislabeled?
A statistical engine “knows” nothing.
Just like you know nothing about caricatures.
deleted by creator
Hm, I prefer the AI copy.
Cheap lazy co-opting fucks.
While the original certainly has an actual style, i have to say that I have no fucking clue what I’m looking at with the trump face
An ugly as hell style (IMO), but a style nonetheless. The AI feels like a fastfood drawing.
They exaggerated Trump’s characteristic pucker
looks like he’s trying to make plane noises
WTF is happening to his face in the original?
I think he’s making airplane noises — maybe the artist wanted to show him as utterly oblivious, and enjoying being a plane
Pucker. Exaggerated.
It’s an old racist trope.
The Making of Arab Stereotypes: Racist Portrayals in Political Cartoons during the 1970s Oil Crisis
I meant Trump’s face?
Lmfao
Interesting. AI cannot make proper caricatures of people’s faces apparently.
Check the labels again. I think this post is a troll though.
When I was studying art in college there was like rules and I forget it was either design class or painting or something but there’s like rules to this stuff and I wish I remembered and I’m gonna try to remember but there’s like a standard like this is already set in stone the tech bros have destroyed everything and people just are unaware that there are already established guidelines i betcha inside of super snooty, pitooty, art critic circles, they would be able to answer my question very quickly.
gestalt principles?
