I’m sure this will be hated here but no where in this article does it state AI caused the outage. It said the vulnerabilities were found using AI, but never specifies how the patches were created/reviewed. So we are just assuming since the patches were large that they used AI to generate them without significant review where someone said “this might be to large to push during business hours”
It seems that it’s not about the patches themselves but about the act of patching. All of this constant patching seems to bring other problems and that’s what we’re seeing.
Yeah, in my opinion we are seeing companies not testing the patches in test environments seeing how they act and releasing beta test versions to the companies that rely on the software to be able to test and fix their own software to ensure it works. That to me is all oversight and management issues. Whether you have 1 patch or 12, they all should have the same approval processes, if anything grouping the 12 together and implementing in a test environment, then making that beta available to the companies you sell the product too.
If the security flaw was so bad that they need to implement something now without prior testing they should have made a public announcement that the systems were being taken down for emergency maintenance to ensure the security of their, and their customers data. Which no company would want to do, thus they would have to decide which patches are actual high level risks, and how to get them tested outside the live version.
My thoughts are that it’s poor management and no oversight. As an example if we look at say the PHP vulnerabilities found. Those flaws were found using AI from what we’ve been told. Companies like Cloudflare went out and developed patches and advised companies/users on how they could implement them to ensure the vulnerabilities were covered. A company/user then would need to review/run those patches in a test environment and see how it acts within their environment. What breaks, how much load it puts on the system… what steps will be needed to update it to work with their environment, if none then verifying it works, setting a schedule and deploying a beta version of their companies products to the companies that relies heavily on them telling them when they will go live.
Those companies/users are then responsible for doing the same.
If someone vibe coding just pushed patches that took services across the nation down for a large number of users without notice, we should see JPMorgan and such filing lawsuits for breaching contacts/terms of use.
I’m not a coder, but after working IT related fields for 15+ years, someone writing a patch doesn’t just get a greenlight by their manager, then their managers VP, or however they have there company structured.
Now if this was your home based projects you use for yourself or maybe family/friends… Sure. Someone could easily just push patches and have no one to answer too.
I’ve been getting wary of futurism articles, they seem to really distort the truth to say what we want to hear, not dissimilar to conservative misinformation sources
Nearly every news site that gets posted on social media is like this. Including lemmy. Most of the accounts posting links here are bots anyway.
It’s in the same idea as citogenesis.
#1 Social media users have a fact that they want hear.
#2 A news site publishes a distorted article about that fact.
#3 Social media users check news for that fact and repost it.
#4 Now other news sites have sources. They publish their own articles about that fact, citing the article and social media.
.
It’s especially problematic about elections and AI. With elections it’s about polling and voter sentiment. None of them are trying to report on reality. They’re publishing whatever they think viewers want to see. That may have some overlap with reality, but it’s not reality.
Same here. This is one of several articles where the headline was not only missleading, but outright wrong.
I am critical of AI and all, but i don’t want my worldview reinforced for the price of truth. I do not consider futurism a valid source any longer.
Because it originally started with doge and there are no smart people in the room to not use AI. Do you seriously think this admin could do anything on their own? They of course, used AI.
A call with over 70 staff who remained at education could not identify the problem, and it was only when staff called members of a team that had been fully eliminated on their personal cell phones that the problem could be fixed. And many from this team were then asked to return to full employment. The second is a loss of institutional memory, and that’s about the loss of expertise. The third is oversight and accountability that has been weakened. And the fourth is independence of federal expertise that has been strained. And lastly, there have been major disruptions to agency operations and organizational stability. So when you look at this pattern across 19 different policy areas, it really shows how much federal workers touch every port of four lives. Communities across the country, from rural farmers to students to families, are paying the price for these cuts.
As the Washington Sun reports, Wall Street and National Security Agency sources have already told Congress that the outages are being triggered due to system updates designed to thwart future attacks by AI.
‘It wasn’t caused by US using AI, it was caused by OTHER PEOPLE using AI!’ Is a meaningless distinction if you’re trying to determine whether the rise in the use of AI (LLMs) is to blame.
I’m sure this will be hated here but no where in this article does it state AI caused the outage. It said the vulnerabilities were found using AI, but never specifies how the patches were created/reviewed. So we are just assuming since the patches were large that they used AI to generate them without significant review where someone said “this might be to large to push during business hours”
It seems that it’s not about the patches themselves but about the act of patching. All of this constant patching seems to bring other problems and that’s what we’re seeing.
Yeah, in my opinion we are seeing companies not testing the patches in test environments seeing how they act and releasing beta test versions to the companies that rely on the software to be able to test and fix their own software to ensure it works. That to me is all oversight and management issues. Whether you have 1 patch or 12, they all should have the same approval processes, if anything grouping the 12 together and implementing in a test environment, then making that beta available to the companies you sell the product too.
If the security flaw was so bad that they need to implement something now without prior testing they should have made a public announcement that the systems were being taken down for emergency maintenance to ensure the security of their, and their customers data. Which no company would want to do, thus they would have to decide which patches are actual high level risks, and how to get them tested outside the live version.
The frightening thing is that scenario is the most plausible one, given the short but catastrophic history of AI.
My thoughts are that it’s poor management and no oversight. As an example if we look at say the PHP vulnerabilities found. Those flaws were found using AI from what we’ve been told. Companies like Cloudflare went out and developed patches and advised companies/users on how they could implement them to ensure the vulnerabilities were covered. A company/user then would need to review/run those patches in a test environment and see how it acts within their environment. What breaks, how much load it puts on the system… what steps will be needed to update it to work with their environment, if none then verifying it works, setting a schedule and deploying a beta version of their companies products to the companies that relies heavily on them telling them when they will go live.
Those companies/users are then responsible for doing the same.
If someone vibe coding just pushed patches that took services across the nation down for a large number of users without notice, we should see JPMorgan and such filing lawsuits for breaching contacts/terms of use.
I’m not a coder, but after working IT related fields for 15+ years, someone writing a patch doesn’t just get a greenlight by their manager, then their managers VP, or however they have there company structured.
Now if this was your home based projects you use for yourself or maybe family/friends… Sure. Someone could easily just push patches and have no one to answer too.
Al found “vulnerabilities”…vibe coder who replaced senior dev. Patches with vibe code from AI.
Yes, AI caused this shit.
I’ve been getting wary of futurism articles, they seem to really distort the truth to say what we want to hear, not dissimilar to conservative misinformation sources
Nearly every news site that gets posted on social media is like this. Including lemmy. Most of the accounts posting links here are bots anyway.
It’s in the same idea as citogenesis.
#1 Social media users have a fact that they want hear.
#2 A news site publishes a distorted article about that fact.
#3 Social media users check news for that fact and repost it.
#4 Now other news sites have sources. They publish their own articles about that fact, citing the article and social media.
. It’s especially problematic about elections and AI. With elections it’s about polling and voter sentiment. None of them are trying to report on reality. They’re publishing whatever they think viewers want to see. That may have some overlap with reality, but it’s not reality.
Same here. This is one of several articles where the headline was not only missleading, but outright wrong. I am critical of AI and all, but i don’t want my worldview reinforced for the price of truth. I do not consider futurism a valid source any longer.
Because it originally started with doge and there are no smart people in the room to not use AI. Do you seriously think this admin could do anything on their own? They of course, used AI.
FAA union president says DOGE fired essential employees without assessment
A new report looks at what the DOGE cuts actually cost the public
‘It wasn’t caused by US using AI, it was caused by OTHER PEOPLE using AI!’ Is a meaningless distinction if you’re trying to determine whether the rise in the use of AI (LLMs) is to blame.
Also, nowhere in this article, nor in the thin article linked, says anything about the Chase outage, AI or otherwise.
All ya gotta post is “AI BAD!” and lemmy stands up and barks like trained seals. 🦭⚽