This is well put. I’m not surprised by the lack of any bans in Standard, but at the same time… if I had my way I’d ban 20 or 30 cards from Standard, just with the goal of getting the power level back where it ought to be.

I can only speculate about what your opponent might have been thinking, but if she really wanted to play with her friends then she is also free to concede at any time. Since she didn’t, she must have seen some value in staying in the match. To be fair, some people are not suited for the “patient teacher” role and maybe that was the case for her. But there’s only so much management of other people’s feelings you can do. Also… she has basically unlimited time to play casual side games with her friends whenever she isn’t in the middle of a tournament.

One thing that I, as an introvert, like about sanctioned tournaments is that nobody has to explain or justify why they are there. You are there to play a pre-determined amount of Magic, against algorithmically selected opponents, you will play exactly that much Magic and will stop playing afterwards, and you are entitled to play because you paid your entry fee.

Divine Arrow just keeps getting better and better.

Actually just strictly worse than Eaten Alive, but probably a good draft pick for the right archetype.

The single most important rule in Magic is this one:

104.3a A player can concede the game at any time. A player who concedes leaves the game immediately. That player loses the game.

This goes not just for games but also matches and tournaments. If you are having a bad time for any reason, you should never let anybody make you feel like you have to keep playing.

That said, I’d encourage you to reframe how you think about the situation.

Like you said, you were probably going to 0-3 anyway due to your inexperience. The primary value you’re going to get at this stage is meeting the regulars and getting your “sea legs” under you so you’ll be better prepared for the next draft. Think of losses as just part of the process.

I don’t know what the prize structure is at your LGS, but last time I drafted at mine, it was “one pack per win”. I like that structure because each round is just as valuable as the others. Even if you’re 0-2 there’s still hope you can win the next one. In large tournaments, players will often drop once they get two or three losses and it’s no longer possible for them to finish well enough to earn prizes.* But small store events are designed so that everybody gets to play for the whole time. You should also get paired against players with similar records, so by the last round you’ll have an opponent whose deck may be as bad as your own.

If you know you’re going to “preemptively concede” your matches, then you should actually just tell the TO to drop you. Don’t wait until you and your opponent get to the table only to concede in person. Formally dropping is better because if there are two drops (or there was an odd number of players to begin with), the tournament software will be able to pair up people who actually want to play.

Assuming there’s an even number of drafters, your early drop does mean that whoever you were going to face doesn’t get to play in that round. That’s a bit of a bummer for them, but if that free win means they get an extra pack, that tends to soften the blow.

If you do continue playing, feel free to tell your opponents “I’m new and my deck is bad”, or keep that info to yourself, as you prefer. Mostly what you’d get out of saying that is letting them know they might need to play slower or explain their actions more thoroughly. I’ve met a wide variety of Magic players; some of them will gleefully stomp a newbie, and some will be happy to take it slow and let you undo (recent) mistakes. You never know which type you’re up against until you get into the game.

Rarely will you meet somebody who will actually get salty about how long it’s taking them to beat you. Those people do exist, but they are jerks and you should try not to stress about making them upset. They were always going to get upset no matter what. If you ever feel like somebody’s behavior is really unacceptable, you can call a judge in the moment, or speak to the TO privately later. And remember the Golden Rule that you are free to leave at any time. Some things aren’t worth putting up with just for the chance to win a booster pack.

IMO it’s poor form for the store to change the format on you at the last minute, but I get that they have to keep all their customers happy. Chaos draft arguably puts everyone on even footing since you can’t really prepare for it and just have to rely on fundamentals, but whether you view that as a good thing or not is a matter of opinion. We’re late in the season right now and people may be burned out on Aetherdrift. In a couple of weeks, Tarkir: Dragonstorm will be out and everybody will be excited to play that. Study up on it and you shouldn’t have to worry about anyone changing the draft format on you for a couple of months.

Have fun out there!

* The other side of the coin: never let anyone make you feel like you’re supposed to drop, or owe it to them to drop. You are entitled to play to the bitter end if you so desire. You are never expected to concede to someone, and you should especially not entertain any offers to concede in exchange for a share of prizes or other consideration – that could get you disqualified or sanctioned.

I guess the two alternate arts are supposed to depict juvenile and adult versions, but it’s weird how similar they are. And they have the same collector number? I don’t pay a lot of attention to those numbers, but is that normal?

Yeah, if you control five dragons, I like your chances of winning the game with or without this enchantment. But that’s not a complaint. This card has good flavor and I’m sure will be popular even if it’s not entirely necessary.

Actually, I have to take back what I said – stun counters don’t work with your plan. Doubling Season only doubles counters on permanents you control.

But overall you’re getting good advice in this thread. Try to have multiple copies of your best cards, and focus more (but not necessarily exclusively) on prosecuting your own plan, as opposed to accounting for everything your opponent might do.

Unfortunately, a lot of your best cards are rares – which is often the case in Magic – and it may be expensive to fill your deck with them. But at least use as many as you can, and find placeholders for the rest while you work on building up your collection.

Since you’re building for Standard, one advantage of having four copies of your cards is that it’ll improve consistency. Sometimes you might find yourself thinking, for example, “I should be able to win next turn as long as I draw a counterspell to answer any removal they might have.” That’ll be a lot more likely to happen if you know you have four, or eight, counterspells in the deck, versus the scattered few in the original list.

Edit: stun counters don’t work; see reply below.

Stun counters and certain cards with the proliferate mechanic could offer ways to get some early defense that also synergize with Doubling Season. Consider these:

• Floodpits Drowner
• Serum Snare
• Reject Imperfection

As others have pointed out, you should decide whether this deck is for Standard or Standard Brawl. If it’s for Standard, go up to four copies of your best cards. If it’s for Standard Brawl (which is where I personally would go, from this starting point), you’ll need a commander – Sita Varma will serve, but one of these might be even better:

• Zimone, Paradox Sculptor
• Oko, the Ringleader
• The Goose Mother

Whichever one you choose, other legends can still be in your maindeck. Bristly Bill is a great choice here.

Good luck and have fun!

There is a community at /c/digital if you’d prefer to use that, but I don’t think there’s anything wrong with using this one.

It’s not a triland, though, is it? This land itself can only ever produce green mana.

I’m kind of underwhelmed by this cycle of rare lands, but also kind of glad about that because it means I won’t have to worry about collecting them all.

I thought it was strange to have a (qualified) Vedalken Orrery effect at uncommon, but then I checked and it’s not as unusual as I thought. But this is probably one of the most expansive and playable cards on that list.

This and anything with Mobilize 3 or greater should combo well with Vito, Fanatic of Aclazotz.

Thanks to Domain and all of the creature-lands, we’re at a point where I welcome the return of some amount of land destruction to Standard.

Combos with Marketback Walker to draw a card and make a zombie for free. Also combos with Innocuous Rat or Infernal Vessel to make two creatures for B. Add Gixian Puppeteer to that deck for additional shenanigans.

Zombie Druid? Would it have killed them to let us use our 2/2 Zombie tokens from previous sets? The rest of this cycle makes tokens with a single creature type; why the one exception?

Another spell that triggers Up the Beanstalk for less than five mana, but this is probably too situational to replace Ride’s End in Standard Overlords decks.

This is clearly better than Cruel Edict and likely even a better choice than Chainer’s Edict for a lot of decks/metagames.

I think “Harmonize” is a fine name for both the card and the mechanic but it’s weird that there’s really no similarity between the two. Maybe some yet-to-be-spoiled card will combine the mechanic and the draw effect.

As for this card… doesn’t seven mana seem like a lot for the Harmonize cost? The cost on Roamer’s Routine seems a lot more reasonable. I feel like they were worried this one would be broken and costed it very conservatively. But it’s probably a medium-high pick in draft even so; I mean, removal is removal.

You’re preaching to the choir when it comes to power creep. But I do think this mechanic fits better in blue than black.