It’s not saying the odds of the RH being incorrect is almost 0, it’s saying the odds that the LEAN code was intentionally written to give a false positive are basically 0.
it’s saying the odds that the LEAN code was intentionally written to give a false positive are basically 0
intentionality is not the issue here, dude
The issue is rather that the Lean Prover itself has had many soundness bugs, including some accidentally exploited by AI-generated proofs, and the odds that it does not have more are basically zero.
Thanks, those links are great! Especially the text by Hales.
I do not believe that mathematicians can be entirely satisfied with a system that claims to be a type theory but that cannot even promise that well-formed terms have a unique type, up to definitional equality.
This seems like a bit of an oversight. Also seems they missed an error in the foundational lean 3 thesis and when they found it, everybody was already speeding along on the lean train. Now lean 4 doesn’t have a similar foundation. Had the error been found immediately after publishing the thesis in 2019, it might not have picked up as much steam. Also, even if unique typing is ever proven, definitional equality will still be undecidable.
Instead of saying:“Lean is based on type theory”, we should say:“lean looks a bit like type theory, but who knows?”
First, watch your tone. Second, I clearly meant that some technique was exploited by the AI generated code to give a false positive. Intentional or accidental both literally mean nothing when talking about something a machine generated.
Sorry, i didn’t really intend to invoke the tone of that scene per se, but somehow felt compelled to reference the line when disagreeing with your statement about what the independent mathematicians’ statement is saying.
Obviously, but I feel comfortable conflating them because I don’t see a reason to find that distinction important in response to an article titled “The AI Riemann hypothesis proof is true, independent mathematicians confirm”.
It’s not saying the odds of the RH being incorrect is almost 0, it’s saying the odds that the LEAN code was intentionally written to give a false positive are basically 0.
intentionality is not the issue here, dude
The issue is rather that the Lean Prover itself has had many soundness bugs, including some accidentally exploited by AI-generated proofs, and the odds that it does not have more are basically zero.
here are some links
see also the list of soundness bugs on djb’s False computer-checked proofs page.
Thanks, those links are great! Especially the text by Hales.
This seems like a bit of an oversight. Also seems they missed an error in the foundational lean 3 thesis and when they found it, everybody was already speeding along on the lean train. Now lean 4 doesn’t have a similar foundation. Had the error been found immediately after publishing the thesis in 2019, it might not have picked up as much steam. Also, even if unique typing is ever proven, definitional equality will still be undecidable.
Instead of saying:“Lean is based on type theory”, we should say:“lean looks a bit like type theory, but who knows?”
Oh, I missed that phrasing when replying myself, good catch.
First, watch your tone. Second, I clearly meant that some technique was exploited by the AI generated code to give a false positive. Intentional or accidental both literally mean nothing when talking about something a machine generated.
Sorry, i didn’t really intend to invoke the tone of that scene per se, but somehow felt compelled to reference the line when disagreeing with your statement about what the independent mathematicians’ statement is saying.
Obviously, but I feel comfortable conflating them because I don’t see a reason to find that distinction important in response to an article titled “The AI Riemann hypothesis proof is true, independent mathematicians confirm”.
One is human error that can be corrected, one is a fundamental fact of the universe.