Andrew

  • Admin @ mtgzone.com, a Magic: the Gathering community
  • More at andrewgioia.com
  • Playing and collecting MTG since Mirage!
  • I ♥️ Legacy Lands, Premodern Parfait Oath, Modern Amulet Titan, and elf tribal

  • 260 Posts
  • 439 Comments
Joined 3 years ago
cake
Cake day: June 9th, 2023

help-circle


  • AndrewMAtoMTGRemembering Kai Budde
    link
    fedilink
    English
    arrow-up
    6
    ·
    edit-2
    1 month ago

    One of the first decks I ever played competitively was an artifact/red deck during Urza’s block constructed that I had seen from him. He of course won the 1999 WC with a better busted version of it too, which I also built for casual play. I loved that deck and still do, some of the most fun I ever had was ramping into Wildfires and Temporal Apertures! I will always think of him when I think of those days.

    I didn’t realize just how much he was the GOAT too. 5 Pro Tour titles and 2 World Championships. Absolutely amazing career and a truly amazing guy.






  • AndrewOPMAtoSpoilers[ECL] Hexing Squelcher
    link
    fedilink
    English
    arrow-up
    7
    ·
    2 months ago

    If the card is targeted by a spell or ability, it gets countered unless the other player pays the ward cost (MTG Wiki).

    If I tried to Shock your Hexing Squelcher, for instance, I’d have to pay 2 life or else the Shock would get countered.













  • AndrewMAtoMTGArena Championship 10 Timeless Metagame Breakdown
    link
    fedilink
    English
    arrow-up
    2
    ·
    3 months ago

    Should be a fun weekend of mardu energy mirrors 🤮 Seems like every format now just has a deck making up 1/3 the meta.

    I love the idea of Timeless and even doing degenerate things, I just wish it was curated a bit better. Still looking forward to catching some of this though.



  • AndrewMAtoMTGBrawl: Our Plans
    link
    fedilink
    English
    arrow-up
    3
    ·
    3 months ago

    it is now clearly MTG Arena’s second most played format

    This is shocking to me, it really goes to show just how big a share commander formats have in the entire game. I wonder if this is just in relation to constructed formats or if they’re also including all draft formats in that too?


  • Kinda surprised at the lack of Dimir Midrange and mono red, especially since they seemed to perform pretty well. I know these types of tournament metas are really insular/unique but still.

    I watch at least a decent amount of Standard on Twitch (mostly @shehar_shenhar) and don’t think I’ve ever seen Bant Airbending. It had 16 players (!) and a terrible 35% win rate. What’s up with that? Was UR just too good against it? I can’t imagine missing so badly with that deck.




  • One of the two controversial “take backs” Seth had: https://www.twitch.tv/magic/clip/VenomousSolidBaconDansGame-LnIY9xnX9rDABQLR

    Ken played Broodspinner off Cavern of Souls so while it was uncounterable, it was still targetable by a counter. Seth goes to sacrifice 2 treasure tokens to play It’ll Quench Ya! but unwinds it himself, remembering out loud that Ken named Spider on his Cavern.

    Not sure how I feel about it; watching it in the moment I felt like he cast that and can’t take it back, but also Ken didn’t call a judge and just went with it. His hands never left the treasures either. I think overall the “spirit of the game” would be that Seth was just thinking out loud and didn’t fully commit to it, but a game like this should definitely require more precision.



  • AndrewMAtoMTGWoTC's comments on standard meta and bans
    link
    fedilink
    English
    arrow-up
    11
    ·
    6 months ago

    I find this to be a pretty crappy argument and outcome. Essentially it’s a lame duck standard with Vivi completely warping the format for 2 months because we need to “think of the RCQ players.” Doesn’t even acknowledge how many will not play an RCQ because of this crappy meta.

    So play Vivi or anti-Vivi the next few months (or get destroyed) then replace your deck when Vivi eats an all but certain ban. Great plan.

    I find it more alarming that they’re doubling down on the overall ban strategy. While they plan to add a few more times during the year, they’re still dodging the real issue. They won’t acknowledge that turbo charging cards over 18 sets in a standard window will require (quite a few) emergency bans!




  • AndrewMAtoSpoilers[EOE] Temporal Intervention
    link
    fedilink
    English
    arrow-up
    2
    ·
    8 months ago

    Yeah I missed the nonland part on the first read and thought wtf this is a better Thoughtseize in eternal formats!

    Treasures work well but not sure if there’s enough reliability otherwise for this to be worthwhile in standard.


  • AndrewMAtoMTGIntroducing Pick-Two Draft: A New Way to Play
    link
    fedilink
    English
    arrow-up
    2
    ·
    9 months ago

    I kinda like the 2-picks-per-pack as it can be easier to get into an archetype or cut something off, I have to think this is more related to 8-man pods failing to fire at LGSes though. I don’t have any data but anecdotally it seems like tabletop drafting is down and maybe this is WotC’s attempt to try to fix that? It’s a shame because I’ve always felt the 8 person, 1 booster box, 3 round setup was perfect.

    Funny that the new 30 pack play boxes still don’t work nicely with this format either 😜