• 111 Posts
  • 1.45K Comments
Joined 3 年前
cake
Cake day: 2024年2月5日

help-circle





  • And insult the creators of the genres by making their craft out to be “pew pew lasers and spaceships?”, there’s a reason why the genres were created, if we just want to make things as simple as easy as possible, just call everything fiction, no need to describe it more. I’m sure you can understand how that’s a terrible idea…? Why even have the genres, if you’re just gonna ignore them anyways?

    Sure, let’s let everything be meaningless so nothing matters, that’s what you want with the world?

    There’s also reasons why there is standards and they don’t just let anyone publish stories in magazines and other established prints. Editors exist so they can separate the chaff from the wheat. If you’re just gonna ignore these standards. It shouldn’t be a shock when you’re rejected.

    You provided nothing to show you have any merit to decide what is and isn’t right, the fact that you’re parading around you’re an author means nothing. Especially if you don’t respect the established covenants of writing particular genres.

    If you self publish, of course you can just incorrectly refer to your stuff as whatever you want, especially so it just sells.




  • What are the differences than?

    These are the differences according to multiple veterans (literary the OG inventors of them…) of Sci fi and Fantasy writing. As well as definitions available on every library as well as Wikipedia and other available sources. We are just supposed to take your word over the proven professionals?

    What are your qualifications other than self pronounced author? Usually when someone just interjects that they are lawyer, or a doctor, or other professional, without providing a detailed response, is just making stuff up.

    Because the difference surely isn’t “it has spaceships”, that’s a gross oversimplification.


  • They aren’t, they are the foundational and distinguishing differences between the scifi and fantasy genres.

    Fantasy doesn’t explain the “magic” or the “tech” it’s all handwaved and is just there as part of the story.

    Scifi on the other hand, the technology is the foundation of the story, and the rest is built off of that.

    Both can use parts of each other, but how the story is built is which dictates which is the primary category it should be in.

    If you can’t understand something, and someone is trying to explain it, does that make them gatekeeping?

    So using those non arbitrary definitions, it’s pretty easy to see DCC is fantasy, along with Star Trek and wars

    Foundation, expanse, Robots, they all fall into the other.


  • The expanse is scifi, it uses believable extensions of our knowledge, they still have thrust mass, they still have deceleration. Thats probably one of the best examples to use as as scifi actually.

    Haven’t consumed the culture.

    And if you’ve read Foundations by Asimov and his other books, it’s all explained how the weirdness is an extension of current knowledge (60 years ago). Asimov created the genre, and he’s written nothing that’s fantasy.

    None of those use handwaving to explain the “technology”.

    Unlike DCC, unlike Star Wars, unlike Star Trek, unlike MCU, etc.

    Read Asimovs definitions on what the difference between fantasy and scifi, he’s the one that pioneered the genre and was editor on countless magazines and other written media.


  • Star Trek is just a space fantasy. Klingons are orcs, Vulcans are elves, teleporters are magic, phasers are wands, and telekinesis is spells. It’s how the stories are told and material within that dictates its genre, not a few aspects like “technology”. Technology has never meant “scifi” technology exists in regular fiction and even non-fiction too. Space ships are part of our current history, a story with it doesn’t become “sci-fi” just for that reason.

    It’s a fantasy in a space setting. Not a scifi in xxx setting.

    For “true” scifi the science and technology are supposed to be a believable extension of our universe, not some magical hand waving away fantasy mumbojumbo. So most of your suggestions fall into the fantasy aspect, most of those can only be explained by hand waving, there’s no basis on reality.

    For FTL, it can be wormholes, instead of magic engines.