I think Canadian mortgage holders are woefully uninformed overall.
Nobody helps them choose an efficient bid price for a house, nobody explains the downside risk of variable mortgages, nobody shows them historic rates or real prices.
We just assume the banks and brokers who look at their household income and down payment amount are doing a good job selecting the right risk level for homeowners, but they really only are incentivized to make a sale (and CMHC and insurance will cover the risks).
The housing market is horribly inefficient and all incentives are to keep it that way, otherwise the unwinding of value would devastate our economy. I’m not trying to ape Micheal Burry or anything like that, my experience buying a house was just eye opening because of how poorly informed buyers are.
The banks, the Realtors and the corpos waiting to turn my home into a rental love it this way. I have a small mortgage in Atlantic Canada, when I bought my home there was a lot of pressure to shop near the top of my pre-approval , which was around $600,000. But to the dismay of my realtor I held out, was flexible, and ultimately found a place for less than half that amount.
If I had just went with the flow, I’d be house poor and spending near $2500 a month on the mortgage, plus much higher property tax and maintenance. I’d also be staring at a fixed rate renewal of close to $3500 a month, or already seen my payments climb near that with a variable rate (another thing they tried to push me into when rates were impossibly low).
And none of them would care, not the realtor who took his cut, not the lender who collects the interest and can repo the hard asset, not the corpo that will buy the home up on fire sale and rent it back to me.
As it is, I’ve insulated myself from rate increases up to a certain amount. But that was all my doing, nobody else gave a lick to help with that.
Nobody helps [borrowers] choose an efficient bid price for a house, nobody explains the downside risk of variable mortgages, nobody shows them historic rates or real prices.
Borrowers are adults. They are about to sign a pretty important document, so they should do a few hours of research. Maybe take a book out of the library. Perhaps look online.
Figuring out historic interest rates is not hard. StatsCan and a dozen other websites show rates going back to the 1950s.
Determining what you can pay is a matter of budgeting, or saying “I can afford my current rent, so the mortgage, maintenance, and taxes need to cost roughly the same”.
The level of effort is similar to doing taxes. Most people who should qualify for a mortgage can do the homework.
I agree in principal, that’s what I did, but that’s not the norm.
Most people just look at the monthly payments and ask for the lowest interest rate number which is usually variable, and they bid with very little strategy getting emotional and pay more than they have to.
I think Canadian mortgage holders are woefully uninformed overall.
Nobody helps them choose an efficient bid price for a house, nobody explains the downside risk of variable mortgages, nobody shows them historic rates or real prices.
We just assume the banks and brokers who look at their household income and down payment amount are doing a good job selecting the right risk level for homeowners, but they really only are incentivized to make a sale (and CMHC and insurance will cover the risks).
The housing market is horribly inefficient and all incentives are to keep it that way, otherwise the unwinding of value would devastate our economy. I’m not trying to ape Micheal Burry or anything like that, my experience buying a house was just eye opening because of how poorly informed buyers are.
The banks, the Realtors and the corpos waiting to turn my home into a rental love it this way. I have a small mortgage in Atlantic Canada, when I bought my home there was a lot of pressure to shop near the top of my pre-approval , which was around $600,000. But to the dismay of my realtor I held out, was flexible, and ultimately found a place for less than half that amount.
If I had just went with the flow, I’d be house poor and spending near $2500 a month on the mortgage, plus much higher property tax and maintenance. I’d also be staring at a fixed rate renewal of close to $3500 a month, or already seen my payments climb near that with a variable rate (another thing they tried to push me into when rates were impossibly low).
And none of them would care, not the realtor who took his cut, not the lender who collects the interest and can repo the hard asset, not the corpo that will buy the home up on fire sale and rent it back to me.
As it is, I’ve insulated myself from rate increases up to a certain amount. But that was all my doing, nobody else gave a lick to help with that.
Everyone involved has a perverse incentive to railroad the buyer into the most expensive house possible. The whole system is rotten.
Borrowers are adults. They are about to sign a pretty important document, so they should do a few hours of research. Maybe take a book out of the library. Perhaps look online.
Figuring out historic interest rates is not hard. StatsCan and a dozen other websites show rates going back to the 1950s.
Determining what you can pay is a matter of budgeting, or saying “I can afford my current rent, so the mortgage, maintenance, and taxes need to cost roughly the same”.
The level of effort is similar to doing taxes. Most people who should qualify for a mortgage can do the homework.
I agree in principal, that’s what I did, but that’s not the norm.
Most people just look at the monthly payments and ask for the lowest interest rate number which is usually variable, and they bid with very little strategy getting emotional and pay more than they have to.