- cross-posted to:
- buyeuropean@feddit.uk
- cross-posted to:
- buyeuropean@feddit.uk
cross-posted from: https://piefed.zip/post/289079
You must log in or register to comment.
BitWarden is F(antastic)OSS.
Aegis ia even better
How? BitWarden has great 2FA, but is also a password manager with good integrations, group sharing, etc. Plus when you log in with it, it auto-copies the 2fa to clipboard.
Assuming you’ve used both, so what does Aegis bring to the table? Wondering if I should try it.
For the same reason you usually shouldnt store 2FA in the passwordmanager.
Besides that Aegis has some features like automated (encrypted) backups when accounts are removed/added.
Also can use multiple different 2FA protocols (even Steam when your phone has root).
2fa only for paying customers, no? I mean, I pay because it’s dirt cheap for tge convenience they offer but still no free 2fa
2fa is free
Bitwarden authenticator is free for non-paying customers too.
deleted by creator
As if I would use a 3rd party to host my bitwarden data.
Eitger 1st party or selfhost. But some unknown 3rd party? Way too risky.
This is a more welcome addition than that stupid AI chatbot slop machine.
But I would still like to see them release Proton Drive for Linux already.
I wouldn’t mind not having a native Linux drive client if they didn’t block rsync, which used to work, and now does not. What a stupid decision.
Fantastic, wish they prioritised stuff like this instead of AI but at least it’s here now. Now please make a dedicated contacts app so I can stop using Google contacts too!
Yeah, I also was disappointed that proton wallet was for crypto and not credit cards. Unless someone can recommend an alternative to Google wallet, preferably from F-Droid
Google Wallet is not so much a “wallet” for your cards but a way to link your cards to their own payment service, Google Pay.
Both Apple and Google had a lot of problems convincing banks to accept their respective services, and even then many stores still don’t support this payment method. A company with the clout and size of Proton has no chance to get their own service widely accepted.
The FSF (and RMS himself) wanted an alternative for online payments for ages, without crypto. An anonymous buffer layer between your payment method, like a credit card, and the vendor. I believe something was eventually released but it never took off, because unlike something like a NFC Wallet, vendors would have to natively support GNU’s version.
I think you are referring to GNU Taler.
It recently started operating in a kind of open beta in Switzerland https://news.itsfoss.com/gnu-taler-swiss-operations/
I started using Curve since I swapped to Graphene. Upsides: it’s not google and it works fine. Downsides: it’s a free as in beer app that (I assume) is selling my data.
I’ve read that Monzo used to have their own NFC payment app, but it looks like that isn’t around anymore and they just integrate with Google Pay now. If anyone knows more about it I would love to hear it.
Same, if they made a wallet for cards then I’d actually use my phone to pay for stuff
Been using Aegis on android and managing my own backups but maybe switch or use for things I care less for just for simplicity
yes Aegis is awesome
Did anyone catch what the Proton app adds over all the already existing apps?
Looks like it has encrypted sync and desktop apps too, so that’s nice if you need stuff on multiple devices.
The sync is the main thing for me. I already back up my Aegis library and upload that to proton drive. Difference in security for me is pretty much zero between Aegis and a proton authenticator app
Why its not available as apk or aab or on fdroid?
Promoting play store?
What’s more, they talk up how it’s open source and then don’t link to the repo.
Here it is, BTW:
I saw it, of cource they didnt publish no apk or aab. I dont think a lot of people will compile from the source code, maybe like 0.05% of users
Is proton legit? I always see mix comments about them.
It’s legit. The negative comments are because the CEO supports US Republican politicians which is a red flag, but there haven’t been any operational reasons to not trust them that I’m aware of.
There are no very clear reasons to distrust proton, but is it just me that finds them releasing a 2FA app kinda disturbing? Like, why waste the resources? What could they do better than Aegis, which is already FOSS and privacy preserving? If there is no reason, than I have to wonder if the hidden reason is to get more data into their ecosystem. Which a privacy focused company shouldn’t care about.
I am probably just paranoid but I don’t trust Proton.
Yes it’s just you. They released a 2FA app because it complements their existing password manager and because Google has one. Since Proton is positioned as a privacy-first alternative to Google, it makes sense they’d launch competing versions of any given app or program Google does. A 2FA app also wouldn’t capture any kind of personal data.
What could they do better than Aegis, which is already FOSS and privacy preserving?
Have an iOS app for one.
But also like what could they do better than Tutanota mail, Which is already privacy preserving? By your logic Proton shouldn’t exist at all. Is it your opinion that non-privacy respecting software should have lots of competition and options but privacy respecting ones should not? Can’t say I agree with that.
Why release this? Because they’re building their own ecosystem. They’re trying to build an alternative to the big players, which means they need to have an alternative to all their major products. Maps and YouTube are probably off the table for now, just because of the sheer scale needed for those, but something like this is achievable.
Is Aegis better? Maybe, but that’s not really the point, it’s part of a family of apps.
Doesn’t support republican politicians. Congratulated the anti-big-tech appointment by a republican politician (Trump).
Definitely supported the Republicans. It was a red flag to hold opinions like this:
Here is our official response, also available on the Mastodon post in the screenshot: Corporate capture of Dems is real. In 2022, we campaigned extensively in the US for anti-trust legislation. Two bills were ready, with bipartisan support. Chuck Schumer (who coincidently has two daughters working as big tech lobbyists) refused to bring the bills for a vote. At a 2024 event covering antitrust remedies, out of all the invited senators, just a single one showed up- JD Vance. By working on the front lines of many policy issues, we have seen the shift between Dems and Republicans over the past decade first hand. Dems had a choice between the progressive wing (Bernie Sanders, etc), versus corporate Dems, but in the end money won and constituents lost. Until corporate Dems are thrown out, the reality is that Republicans remain more likely to tackle Big Tech abuses.
He’s not wrong about the Democrat party choosing the establishment over the progressive wing, but the idea that he supports the Republicans as being more likely to reign in tech companies is so laughable it’s not even funny, and makes you wonder why Andy Yen believes it.
What other commenters have said before though is true: aside from this incident with the CEO, Proton has been careful to stay politically neutral and on message… It damaged their public trust but didn’t destroy it.
Which then turned out to be not exactly true.
Just like Tesla. Its AOKAY to jump into a new company even if the CEO is a crazy racist.
I don’t think there’s any evidence he’s a crazy racist that we know of.
It works, has minor quirks, but it has replaced a lot of things for me, switched from Google gmail, drive, and calendar to Protons and it has been good. (Though the whole Lumo AI release move confused me) Oh yeah VPN too, well for other countries, still use my wireguard vpn when traveling.
But personally, I’mma continue sticking to Aegis as my authenticator app. (Can’t recommend it enough)
Aegis is my go-to. But I also have two phones - my personal Pixel and a work-issued iPhone. I need 2FA on my work phone, but Aegis doesn’t support iOS. Proton came through here. It’s open-source, too.
I’ve been meaning to get rid of Google Authenticator. Think I’m gunna go do that today. :)
Consider Aegis if you want an offline and secure alternative.
Aren’t all 2FA apps offline compatible?
Should be, but not all of them allow you to opt-out of cloud sync.
(And Aegis has amazing backup features like backup after changes to accounts.)
Proton does this as well, you can use it completely offline without an account
Can you export accounts in (encrypted) json?
They do advertise direct export, but I’m not sure if that means encrypted json
Good to hear. I’ll try it once it is on fdroid
Ehhhh but they already have this in Proton Pass?
E: found this in the FAQ
Proton Pass is a password manager designed to securely generate and store strong passwords, and protect your digital identity with features like email alises and dark web monitoring. It also includes an integrated authenticator that can store and autofill 2FA codes - but not the ones used to log in to your Proton account. Proton Authenticator is a standalone 2FA app that allows users to enable 2FA protection for their Proton account, it also allows users to store their 2FA codes separate from their passwords if they wish to do so.
If you already use Proton Pass, I think I’d recommend Ente Auth instead. That’s what I use.
You really should not keep your MFA codes in the same place as your passwords, especially if you are syncing those passwords between devices and/or a cloud service.
Yes that’s why I said:
If you already use Proton Pass, I think I’d recommend Ente Auth instead
Aha. Sorry, I misunderstood. I saw the first line about Proton Pass already supporting MFA and I wasn’t familiar with Ente Auth. I did just look it up and I can’t believe I’ve never heard of it before. It’s even AGPL-3.0, be still my beating heart! Thank you for pointing it out!
https://ente.io/ for anyone curious.
I use ente photos too and I like it
Yes, the biggest difference is that Proton Auth seems to work without an account.
Thank you for your comment. I was also confused initially before reading properly. I thought, ‘What? But isn’t the Proton 2FA thing paid? What do they gain by making it free?’ It seems that most people are not willing to use this new app, though. Ente, Aegis, whatever the alternative is, there doesn’t seem to be a reason to use this new authenticator from Proton instead. I wonder what their goal is here. Is it simply to expand their app ‘ecosystem’?
There are ads in the app for Proton Pass, so that’s my best guess.
It is very wise to store your 2FA codes separately from your general login credentials. If one is breached, the other protects it (hence, two factor). If both are breeched, your account is hosed.
Same deal when setting up 2FA on an account and they provide some ‘one time use’ 2FA codes, they generally say ‘do not store these with your standard password credentials - keep them secure and separate’.
Correct. However it’s worth noting that passwords are almost always compromised server-side. So 2FA is far more a mitigation of data breaches from the provider, rather than your password manager being breached.
Feels like everyone has forgotten when LastPass was breached, and that was barely three years ago.
Any affected LastPass users storing their 2FA backup codes in with the rest of their login data got a rude awakening.
Anyone who had them separate was at least able to rescue those accounts. But hey do what you like people, I know convenience usually trumps security.
As far as I know, passwords and TOTP keys were never leaked by LastPass. Regardless, I did say almost always.
Hmm… I’m not sure about having an authenticator app on a desktop computer.
Like you are putting all your eggs in one basket. Password managers, and your emails already go to one place for authentication. Adding an authenticator means if your computer is compromised, a person can have access to more accounts.
I always figured this is why desktop authenticator apps aren’t a thing.
No company phone = Me using a desktop app for work related 2FA.
Not my problem.
The alternative for people who want a convenience factor is putting it all in the same location. For example, the only thing Authy for desktop closing did for me was make it so I no longer had an isolated app for both 2FA and passwords, because now it’s just all in my password manager.
I don’t always have my phone on me 24x7, so the inability to access things on my desktop is a massive nope for me.
The way I looked at it, it’s no different than having a mobile device with a password manager on it, because if someone steals your mobile device, they have access to everything as well. So the two-factor authentication apps shouldn’t be on desktop argument never made sense to me, mobile is the same way.
This application might make me go back into having the two isolated systems, because it removes the massive inconvenience factor
So the two-factor authentication apps shouldn’t be on desktop argument never made sense to me, mobile is the same way.
I think that argument was rooted in the assumption that the phone was a separate and smaller attack surface. The assumption is reasonable if you use your credentials mostly on desktop and only have a few apps on your phone, which was indeed the case for a lot of people in the past.
But nowadays, a lot of people use the same credentials on the phone just as well, and with everything asking to install their app, I’m not sure the attack surface really is smaller anymore. So, if you’re in this scenario, I agree with you that you may not be sacrificing much by having 2FA on desktop.
And, of course, 2FA, even in the same password manager, is still better than none. Your first factor can be stolen in more ways than just compromising your machine, for example through data breaches.
But nowadays, a lot of people use the same credentials on the phone just as well, and with everything asking to install their app, I’m not sure the attack surface really is smaller anymore. So, if you’re in this scenario, I agree with you that you may not be sacrificing much by having 2FA on desktop.
This makes sense and puts holes in my statement. I also feel like more people are willing to install shady stuff on their phones than their desktop now. I have no sources for this though.
That makes sense. I hadn’t really looked at it from the angle of most apps are going on devices anyway. Mine was just because of the fact that it’s super annoying having to have my phone on me at all times for two-factor authentication. Especially considering that most 2FA apps require you to sign in in order to use them anyway.
Also, yeah, that was my ideology when I threw them into my password manager. That if they can manage to breach a device, find my private key that’s used to lock the database and figure out the password for the database. Something far worse has gone wrong and losing my passwords is the least of my issues.
The way I looked at it, it’s no different than having a mobile device with a password manager on it, because if someone steals your mobile device, they have access to everything as well. So the two-factor authentication apps shouldn’t be on desktop argument never made sense to me, mobile is the same way.
That is true. And more phones are stolen now than computers. Computers can have the same security and encryption if properly configured.
Even though you make a logical point, something in my gut doesn’t feel right.
These are great points, but there is something more that phones have going for them.
All modern phones are full-disk encrypted by default, and can be remote wiped. I think this is only the case for Mac laptops, but not for Linux and Windows.
So if your phone is stolen, it’s not really a risk of the thief having your password manager and your 2FA at the same time, but rather can they get in to your phone and then password manager and 2FA before you can trigger the remote wipe.
Unless the attacker is sophisticated enough to mirror the whole disk and attack it offline.
Yeah. You have great points. A lot easier to wipe a device that is actively connected. Laptops don’t usually have that luxury. It is a lot easier to take apart a laptop. It is easier to plug in a USB HID for brute forcing or to constantly move a pointer to prevent it from going to sleep.
I guess that’s the feeling in my gut.
Thank you for your input.
Well hopefully the 2FA data is encrypted and the app requires a pin or password to access.
Plus my password manager also needs a pin after it times out, and my computers all have their drives encrypted too.
It’s plenty to stop casual thieves and such.
Absolutely. 2FA codes (and 2FA ‘single use codes’ / recovery codes) should not be stored in the same system that manages your usernames and passwords - it defeats the purpose of 2FA.
But most people will just breeze past advice and do whatever is most convenient.
I don’t view it as simply compromised or not. How a password is compromised is relevant. The vast majority of issues aren’t somebody gaining access to your logged in machine. Passwords are nearly always compromised from a server mishandling data.
That means in most cases 2FA near a password is not likely to be an issue. I’m not saying I recommend it, but it does change the risk evaluation.
I am (was?) one of those. Working on eliminating or changing the passwords and emails of my 550+ accounts. I’m creating a simplelogin email for each of the ones I’m keeping, setting up a randomly generated password for each as well (24+ characters long with every possible character available), trying to delete the accounts of services I don’t want/need anymore, and then setting up 2fa on Aegis if they don’t accept a hardware tokens.
But it’s an intense and long process, though absolutely worth it. With work and personal life, I’m guessing I can be done in a couple of weeks.
fuck yeah, goodbye authy
Why? What’s wrong with Authy? I use it, Proton and Bitwarden. I could consolidate everything into Proton, but I’m concerned about having everything with one vendor.
as above trying to get away from american services, it’s really, youtube, google maps and iphone are only things im stuck with
I wish there was a good alternative to YouTube. I’ve been meaning to host a Peertube instance but that process is really not as straightforward as it should be if they want the platform to gain widespread adoption
Google Maps has pretty decent alternatives though:
- For simply browsing the map I use OpenStreetMaps on desktop, and Organic Maps on mobile.
- For navigation (by car) I used to use Waze (which is also owned by Google), but I’ve switched back to good ol’ TomTom
As for iPhone… personally I have a Google Pixel which I’m going to keep using till I can’t anymore. After that I’m probably switching to Fairphone. They’re a European company and their phones are right up my alley
Not op, but for me the main problem with Authy is that it is owned by an American company.
It’s not the worst offender, but any American company is subject to the whims of the current administration. As an example, we’re currently seeing how American sanctions lock people out of their Microsoft accounts at the International Court.
I’ve slowly been moving over my 2FA codes to Aegis.
I guess it’s kinda nice. They already had this in Proton Pass, but I guess not all accounts have access to that as a bundle maybe?
Proton Pass is a password manager designed to securely generate and store strong passwords, and protect your digital identity with features like email alises and dark web monitoring. It also includes an integrated authenticator that can store and autofill 2FA codes - but not the ones used to log in to your Proton account. Proton Authenticator is a standalone 2FA app that allows users to enable 2FA protection for their Proton account, it also allows users to store their 2FA codes separate from their passwords if they wish to do so.
Seems like basically an ad platform/gateway to Pass.
That’s amazing
Netflix doesn’t have 2FA
I currently have all of my 2FA codes in Pass except for my Proton account itself, which I have in Aegis, backing up to my home server.
It looks like you can easily export from Aegis to Proton Authenticator and you can use PA without a Proton account, which I think I might do. I don’t want to use my PA app with my Proton account to hold my Proton account 2FA code. I’ll end up locked out of the house with the keys inside.
Wow an OTP app.
Maybe a QR creation app is next?
