• 4 Posts
  • 64 Comments
Joined 8 个月前
cake
Cake day: 2025年3月12日

help-circle





  • To address your original question more squarely - I might use such a resource if it was free. First because the rarity tiers are poorly thought out and second because even if characters are networking through factor/dealers instead of browsing a shopkeeper’s dispaly case - you still have to assign a price.

    The 1st Edition DM’s Guide gave every wondrous item its own specific gold piece value. The relative valuations weren’t perfect but I was shocked when I came back to D&D in 5E to find per-item valuation was abandoned. If I was going to tackle the problem myself, I’d refer to the 1E DMG valuations as a starting point for consumables like potions and scrolls, then consult a few of the most popular “magic item tier guide” articles to supplement 5E’s overly broad and internally flawed valuation by arbitrary rarity tags.

    Classic example, the merely “Uncommon” Weapon of Warning is arguably a keeper all the way to endgame. Many DMs even nerf away its party-wide benefits entirely, because making the whole group reliably immune to surprise is game-breaking. You could gain the same personal benefit, and free up the attunement slot, by spending a precious Feat slot to take the Alert feat - but even that doesn’t compare with also making all allies within 30’ immune to surprise.

    If you survey the 1E magic item valuations, it helps to be aware that a) attunement slots weren;t a thing - you could equip a lot more magic! Also, b) wands in general and many other “spend a charge” items did not regain X number of charges every day. A Wand of Fireballs with 50 charges was worth about 50 Scrolls of Fireball - and when you spent the last charge, it was just a nonmagical stick again.