I don’t think anyone has a problem with bottle episodes. It’s the bottle episodes specifically starring Vic Fontaine which stretches the premise thin to incredulity that I think people–or at least I–have an issue with. Do another Ferengi or Klingon thing if need be. But attaching such sentiment to a character that the show really really wants you to like doesn’t work for me. Again, he’s a love him or hate him character. At least Ezri’s episodes, while shoehorned, made sense for why they needed to be there if they had to have her as a replacement at all. Vic was just an insert the writers specficially wanted for no good reason.
Hmm, so basically exactly the people you’d expect to be traded. I guess it’s a silver lining for this season going so terribly that moving pieces that are actually working for us won’t hurt too terribly and we can try to get as much in return as possible without worrying so much of how we’ll survive the postseason.