Random thoughts in no particular order:

• The writing seems clear after a skim.
• The formatting is ugly as all hell. If you want a plain document with nice formatting, can I recommend LaTeX?
• Given that indie projects are only read by people who read indie RPG projects, maybe the ‘what is an RPG’ section could swap out for ‘very fast rules summary’. But I guess the “Philosophy” section covers that.
• With all the emphasis on time tracking, maybe provide a character sheet which lets you pin-point things which will happen at a particular time? Like coins for 10-minute tracker, and pencilled-in events for the months-long actions?
• I don’t understand this magic system.

The apps are certainly in need of all the help they can get. I have Lemur and Jerboa, and they’re both janky as all heck.

About 50% of what I read online is just RSS. For cli fans, newsboat lets you extend the RSS feeds really easily. So far, I have:

• gemini translation, to get gemini feeds, and a hotkey to open them.
• a hotkey to open things in w3m (most articles work fine in the terminal, many are easier to read)
• a hotkey to open youtube videos
• another to download them and watch later

Haggis whiskers are similar, but quite rare nowadays.

One of the greatest joys of federation, is de-federation.

Kbin is very young software. The dev was doing really well, then /u/spez dumped 10-bajillion users on it. I’m surprised the servers are still operating.

Lemmy’s a lot more mature, but it’s never been tested with this kind of traffic. It’s impressive that any of these sites are still going. I’d give it at least another month until things settle, adjustments are made, instances update, et c. et c.

An art instance is a brave move. Lemmy takes up a lot of disk space already, but encouraging images means a lot more disk space. Lemmy also allows multiple images per post.

I don’t think anyone can tell where we’re going. Mastodon.social was the largest instance by far for some time, then at the deluge, it splintered.

Part of the reason for Mastodon to fracture is specialization - each instance does something unique. Maybe Lemmy will do the same, maybe not.

But if we end up with 3 primary instances, it’s still decentralized - I think the most useful feature of Lemmy isn’t that we’re spread out, it’s that we could be.

More like a teenager with their first job.

This week, Lemmy becomes a man.

In all fairness to the devs, Lemmy’s had a dozen users + the devs until now, then /u/spez pulls his stunt, and we’re looking at how it operates with 0.0000000000001% of Reddit, which is apparently 20-bajillion people.

The features sound good, and judging by Lemmy, I imagine they’re coming, depending on how much free time the devs have.

there’s no reason for a general-purpose instance to defederate from lemmynsfw.com

This one’s trickier. The mods have mentioned both moderation and legal difficulties with nsfw instances. If something illegal’s posted, then whoever has the server would (verifiably) have a copy of that image and has been (verifiably) distributing it. Reddit probably managed to skirt these issues by a) being early, when the world was new, and laws were weak, and b) having the money for a legal team.

I wouldn’t want to be an admin trying to answer legal questions.

There’s a Github issue about it here.

There’s a lot to answer on what exactly that would mean. Would you be able to edit old posts from the new instance? What if the new instance already defederated from the old? Would you retain the same username? Or are you simply getting a list of subscriptions, and copying them across?

Users are unable to block whole instances

Sounds like a good feature, though not exactly a ‘disadvantage’, without a comparison. Is the comparison Mastodon? Reddit?

Lemmy is one of the least privacy friendly service I have ever stumbled upon

Could you expand on this? Is it just the deletion problem?

There is no possibility to migrate or backup your subscribed/favorited stuff or even move it to another instance (which somehow is possible on Mastodon),

This took a while to get on Mastodon. Remember, the data’s not necessarily stored in a usable format (users don’t want a load of postgres in their download), and the devs need to be sure that nobody else’s data will accidentally get in there.

Kbin is new, the distinctions between Magazine and micro-blogging creates an extra barrier to understand the system, the few instances are straining under the load, and it’s very much in beta.

New users won’t be terribly forgiving, so I feel like Lemmy’s the better option.

I never understood why questionable views from software devs might be a problem.

• It’s not a corporation, so you’re not financially supporting tankies.
• Lots of devs don’t share your values, because everyone has different values.

It’s not like I can only use software made by people who don’t eat meat, and everyone’s doctors are partially informed by science performed by the Nazis.

I have no idea what kind of world these people think they’re living in, as if everything were developed with shared values, and a pure conscience, until Lemmy came along.