One of the inventors of Siri, the original AI agent, wants you to “handle with care” when it comes to artificial intelligence. But are we becoming too cautious around AI in Europe and risking our future?

  • MangoCats@feddit.it
    link
    fedilink
    English
    arrow-up
    1
    ·
    1 小时前

    A door lock can’t buy up Amazon’s entire stock of tide pods on my credit card.

    But it can let in a burglar who can find your credit card inside and do the same. And why are you giving AI access to your CC#? You’d better post it here in a reply so I can keep it safe for you.

    A door lock can’t turn on someone’s iot oven while they’re out of town.

    But it can let in neighborhood children who will turn on your gas stove without lighting it while you’re out of town.

    A door lock can’t publish every email some journalist has ever received to xitter.

    True, the journalist, or his soon-to-be-ex-spouse, can “accidentally” do that themselves - and I suppose the ex-spouse who still has a copy of the key can “fool” the lock with that undisclosed copy of the key while the journalist is out having sushi with his mistress.

    A mechanical door lock doesn’t hallucinate extra fingers, and draw them into all the family photos saved on a person’s hard drive.

    I’ve worked with AI for a while now, it’s not going to up and hallucinate to do that - unless you ask it to do something related.

    • atrielienz@lemmy.world
      link
      fedilink
      English
      arrow-up
      1
      ·
      55 分钟前

      But it can let in a burglar who can find your credit card inside and do the same. And why are you giving AI access to your CC#? You’d better post it here in a reply so I can keep it safe for you.

      You aren’t giving your door lock access to your credit card information. And it didn’t “let the burglar in” so much as it has a failure ceiling. Meaning that there is more of a chance that a burglar can get in than zero, but less of a chance than if you didn’t have a lock at all. An outside party is circumventing the protections you put into place to protect your credit card number. Or perhaps (possibly) you are circumventing it by accident by leaving the door lock unlocked.

      However, in both those cases, the door lock is not doing anything of its own volition, and won’t be doing that outside your control. The AI LLM is doing stuff both of its own volition (perhaps within parameters you set, but more likely outside of parameters you set, but within parameters the company that makes it set and only that to a degree).

      You don’t do any banking except in person? Any shopping except in person with cash? Because that’s what you’re suggesting when you say things like “why are you giving it access to your credit card”.

      Microsoft is suggesting that they will run “Agentic AI” on the windows 11 computers of hundreds of millions of peoples personal devices in the background without their direct input, and that this AI may download malware or be a threat vector that malicious apps, services, etc can take advantage of. But they’re going to do it anyway.

      Microsoft is not installing door locks in my house, and if they tried I’d kindly escort them off the property, by force if necessary.