• QuoVadisHomines@sh.itjust.works
    link
    fedilink
    arrow-up
    6
    arrow-down
    1
    ·
    6 hours ago

    Surely people going to jail for the wrong reason is something exclusive to the Soviet Union and not to all countries with a legal system?

    It isn’t common for people to be sent to slave camps as a punishment for years without knowing why they were charged. That’sthe kind of evil unique to totalitarian shitholes like the USSR.

    Your boss may have spent his teens in a gulag, but the fact that he lived to tell you that is because the Soviets managed to miraculously defeat the Nazis and prevent them from genociding the Slavic peoples they categorised as “Untermenschen” according to the infamous “Generalplan Ost”, which implied genocide of almost all people between Germany and the Urals. If it wasn’t for the Soviets, your former boss would have been murdered in a concentration camp by the nazis.

    The same nation you are praising put him IN a concentration camp for no fucking reason other than potentially because of his race.

    Like, damn, I feel sorry for your boss, but in dire circumstances such as those of the late 30s / early 40s in the USSR, excesses and abuses were sadly made because of the overwhelming conditions.

    No, you don’t. You wouldn’t be supporting their evil actions in this case if you had any empathy.

    You are making a lot of apologies for overt racism, why are you doing this and why do you think the USSR’s racism should be praised?

    • AES_Enjoyer@reddthat.com
      link
      fedilink
      English
      arrow-up
      1
      arrow-down
      1
      ·
      2 hours ago

      It isn’t common for people to be sent to slave camps as a punishment for years without knowing why they were charged

      Ever heard of Abu Ghraib or Guantanamo?

      That’sthe kind of evil unique to totalitarian shitholes like the USSR.

      The Gulag episode lasted less than two decades, by the mid-50s it was a thing of the past and never resurfaced in the country. Almost as if it was a mass hysteria response to Nazi infiltration, and not born out of a desire to oppress people inherently. Again, at the peak of the Gulag system, the prison population was similar to that of modern USA. Much more authoritarian if you ask me

      The same nation you are praising

      Yes, I’m praising this nation because even if it did mistakes, by industrialising eastern Europe and by eliminating Nazis it saved hundreds of millions of lives.

      You wouldn’t be supporting their evil actions in this case if you had any empathy

      I’m not supporting the excesses of the Gulag repression, it’s something that we can and should criticise. I’m supporting the rest of things of the country, which led to the saving of hundreds of millions of people from hunger, disease and Nazi genocide. The Gulag repression seems horrible until you realize the Nazis murdered 27 million Soviets at that time. It was an extreme measure carried out in extreme times.

      You are making a lot of apologies for overt racism

      I’m not. If he was jailed for his race that’s wrong. You’re just making too much criticism of the country thst saved Europe from fascism and which saved hundreds of millions of lives in the process.