towhee [he/him]

  • 1 Post
  • 8 Comments
Joined 7 days ago
cake
Cake day: November 7th, 2025

help-circle






  • It’s good rhetoric. Game it out:

    Option 1, he says this; nobody can actually say they’re against equal rights for all citizens, so zionists revert to repeating & emphasizing the phrase “israel has a right to exist as a Jewish state” and sound like complete fucking psychopaths on the precipice of voicing recognizable white supremacist rhetoric

    Option 2, he says something like “no, israel does not have a right to exist” to which there are numerous responses such as “then why does Palestine have a right to exist”, to which probably people here would make an argument on the basis of indigeneity, but zionists have their own well-funded competing claim to indigeneity, and then you’re dragged into tedious historical arguments about things that happened thousands of years ago that nobody really gives a fuck about.

    Making any sort of argument based on the validity of indigenous ethnostates is shaky ground at the best of times, especially for leftists who largely aren’t sympathetic to nationalism (let alone ethnonationalism), at most viewing it as a useful unifying force to kick out foreign colonizers after which point it becomes a reactionary tool of the domestic ruling class.